| Universalist | Unitarian | Unitarian-Universalist |
|---|
| Everett L. Rexford | 1880-1887 |
Thomas J. Mumford | 1851-1860 |
Dr. Augustus P. Reccord | 1934-1939 |
| Lee Sullivan McCollester DD | 1882-1912 |
Richard Metcalf | 1860-1861 |
Dr. Tracy Pullman | 1940-1967 |
| Willis Albert Moore DD | 1913-1918 |
S. S. Hunter | 1862-1863 |
Anthony Richard Perrino | 1969-1972 |
| Charles Franklin Patterson | 1919-1922 |
A. G. Hibbard | 1864-1866 |
Dr. John Nichols Booth (interim) | 1972-1973 |
| Frank Durward Adams DD | 1923-1933 |
J. F. Walker | 1866-1868 |
Rudolph C. Gelsey | 1973-1983 |
| Clay MacCauley | 1868 |
Stanley Aronson (extension) | 1985-1988 |
| W. R. G. Mellen | 1869-1871 |
Dr. Richard S. Hasty (interim) | 1988-1990 |
| Calvin Stebbins | 1872-1879 |
Terasa G. Cooley | 1990-1993 |
| T. B. Forbush | 1879-1886 |
Bruce Johnson (interim) | 1993-1995 |
| Reed Stuart | 1886-1909 |
Larry G. Hutchison | 1995-2004 |
| E. R. Shippen | 1910-1918 |
David B. Parke (interim) | 2004-2005 |
| Dr. Augustus P. Reccord | 1919-1934 |
Diana Heath (interim) | 2005-2006 |
| | |
| |
Drew Johnston (interim) | 2007 |